8 mattresses · online only
Every BedStory mattress, who each one is for and the catch to know, plus its returns and where to try one.
Best for: Budget medium-firm hybrid
A Euro-top pocket-coil hybrid in 12″, 13″ or 14″, with thicker support foam as the height goes up.
Good to know: No Twin or Twin XL, and the 12″ has no Cal King.
Best for: Euro-top everyday hybrid
A medium-firm Euro-top hybrid on 9.8″ pocket coils, in 12″, 13″ or 14″.
Good to know: No Twin or Twin XL, and the 12″ has no Cal King.
Best for: Back and stomach sleepers
A medium-firm Euro-top hybrid on 9.8″ pocket coils, in 12″ or 14″, which BedStory doesn’t recommend for side sleepers.
Good to know: Full comes only in 12″ and Cal King only in 14″.
Best for: Extra-firm support
An extra-firm Euro-top hybrid rated 8 to 9 out of 10 on BedStory’s scale, in 12″ or 14″.
Good to know: Twin and Full are 12″ only, and Cal King is 14″ only.
Best for: Extra-firm, low sinkage
An extra-firm Euro-top hybrid on 9.8″ pocket coils, in 12″, 13″ or 14″.
Good to know: No Twin, and the 12″ has no Cal King.
Best for: Hot sleepers wanting plush
A cool-touch pocket-coil hybrid with 2″ to 4″ of gel memory foam, getting plusher as it gets taller.
Good to know: The Twin is 38″ × 74″ and the Full 53″ × 74″, shorter than standard, and only the 14″ comes in Cal King.
Best for: Cool all-foam plush
An all-foam cooling mattress with a cool-touch cover and 4″ to 6″ of gel memory foam in total, depending on height.
Good to know: Only the 14″ comes in Cal King, and the 13″ Full is marked unavailable.
Best for: Zoned support, three firmnesses
A zoned-coil hybrid with a Tencel and cashmere top, Extra Firm at 12″, Firm at 13″ and Medium Firm at 14″.
Good to know: The Twin and Full are 74″ long, an inch shorter than standard, and only the 14″ comes in Cal King.
We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. How we choose and research
365-night trial from delivery for orders on bedstory.com (Amazon and other retailers handle their own returns). Contact support to start; BedStory arranges pickup, and refunds take 5-7 business days after the return is confirmed. One return or exchange per customer, household or address. The trial page says regular-priced items are refundable but sale items may not be, and that returns for personal reasons pay their own shipping, while the return-policy page says trial mattress returns are free. Partial refunds possible for excessive wear or staining; the mattress must have been used with a protector; no PO box returns.
BedStory sells under its own name. bedstory.com
BedStory sells online only as far as we know. Its trial is the way to try it: 365-night trial from delivery for orders on bedstory.com (Amazon and other retailers handle their own returns). Contact support to start; BedStory arranges pickup, and refunds take 5-7 business days after the return is confirmed. One return or exchange per customer, household or address. The trial page says regular-priced items are refundable but sale items may not be, and that returns for personal reasons pay their own shipping, while the return-policy page says trial mattress returns are free. Partial refunds possible for excessive wear or staining; the mattress must have been used with a protector; no PO box returns..