Calistoga Mattress

Name: Custom Comfort Mattress Calistoga Mattress
Brand: Custom Comfort Mattress

Best for: Latex or foam over coils, flippable

A modern profile hybrid mattress with double-sided medium-plush support and natural materials, 10″ tall, made in Custom Comfort's Southern California factory in Twin through Cal King, including Full XL.

Good to know: No returns (hygiene), but a 365-night Comfort Guarantee lets the factory adjust or rebuild the firmness; any other size can be built to order.

Type: Hybrid
Height: 10″
Sizes: Made to order + custom

Made to your measurements · 10″

Where to get it

customcomfortmattress.comQueen $6,285 · checked Oct 17 Get a quote

Returns: No returns (hygiene); 365-Night Comfort Guarantee: in-home or factory firmness adjustments/rebuilds in the first year Details

We may earn a commission if you buy. Check the price for your exact size and height on the seller’s site.

The short version

Worth a look if

Latex or foam over coils, flippable

Good

A modern profile hybrid mattress with double-sided medium-plush support and natural materials, 10″ tall, made in Custom Comfort's Southern California factory in Twin through Cal King, including Full XL.
Trial: No returns (hygiene); 365-Night Comfort Guarantee: in-home or factory firmness adjustments/rebuilds in the first year
Height: 10″
Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full XL, Queen, King, Cal King

Think about

No returns (hygiene), but a 365-night Comfort Guarantee lets the factory adjust or rebuild the firmness; any other size can be built to order.
No owner reviews we could verify yet

Based on the maker’s published specs and terms, and the owner reviews linked below. We haven’t slept on it. Something wrong? Tell us.

What owners say

No owner reviews we can verify yet A small set of real reviews, each linked to its source. Not a star rating.

No independent owner feedback naming this model was found or researched.

What people liked

No supported praise summary in the sample.

What to weigh up

No substantive concern verified in this small sample. This is a gap in the evidence, not proof of no drawbacks.

Sources & sample limits

None Sample: 0 owner reports.

Store-sold model; independent owner reviews by model name were not found in this pass.

Research checked October 14, 2026. These are sourced observations, not our own product tests or a star rating.

Every size it comes in

Made around your measurements. The maker confirms width, length, height and any cut corners before building it.

How it compares

Beside the most similar mattresses from other brands.

	Calistoga MattressCustom Comfort Mattress	Grand Luxe MattressAvocado	M5 Performance MattressBedgear	M5 Night Ice Performance MattressBedgear
Type	Hybrid	Hybrid	Hybrid	Hybrid
Queen price	$6,285	$8,499	$4,000	$4,500
Height	10″	—	14″	14″
Trial	365 nights	100 nights	See terms	See terms
Odd sizes	None	None	None	None
Expert reviews	None yet	None yet	1	1

What’s inside

1100% Organic Cotton Sateen Fabric
2Organic Wool
3Needle Punch Wool
4Quiltable Latex
5Quilted Backing
6All-Natural Latex Padding
7Innerspring Core With Latex Perimeter

Feel: Medium Plush
Height: 10″
Custom sizes: Yes, the maker builds to your measurements

Returns and ordering

Trial and returns

No returns (hygiene); 365-Night Comfort Guarantee: in-home or factory firmness adjustments/rebuilds in the first year

Before you order

Measure inside the frame, not the old mattress
Check clearance above for the height you pick
Make sure your base supports it
Buy sheets in the same exact size

Questions

What is it made of?

A modern profile hybrid mattress with double-sided medium-plush support and natural materials. (Medium Plush, Reserve Collection). 10″ tall without topper. Layers: 100% Organic Cotton Sateen Fabric; Organic Wool; Needle Punch Wool; Quiltable Latex; Quilted Backing; All-Natural Latex Padding; Innerspring Core With Latex Perimeter. Details: A simple process converts 1.4 lbs. of this natural fiber into dense dry-felted protective batting. Eco-friendly and breathable. 2" of plant-based, non-toxic material on both sides of the core. This padding is naturally hypoallergenic, antimicrobial, mold, and dust mite resistant. Traditionally constructed with individually-wrapped Bolsa comfort coils to provide consistent, contouring support with a low-motion transfer feel. Firm edging support with 5" thick natural latex border.

How firm is it?

Medium Plush That’s the maker’s description; we haven’t measured it.

Which sizes and heights can I get?

It’s made to your measurements. Confirm your exact size and height with the seller.

Are the reviews about this exact mattress?

No owner reviews we can verify yet. Store-sold model; independent owner reviews by model name were not found in this pass.

Where did this information come from?

Checked 2026-10-17. Specs and terms can change.