Icon · Review
Sealy Icon Review - Cheap Price; Hard Pass
NapLab · YouTube ↗
1 / 1Images: Sealy. Shown size and configuration may vary.
Icon
Best for: Two heights, three feels
A coil bed with air, gel and support foams, as a 12″ tight top in Soft or Firm, or a 14″ Soft pillow top.
Good to know: The 90-night trial applies only to sealy.com purchases, and one owner wished their 12″ Icon were a bit softer.
- Type
- Hybrid
- Height
- 12″ or 14″
- Sizes
- 8 ready-made
Pick it if
- You sleep hot
- You share the bed
Skip it if
- You need firm edges
From independent reviewers’ findings, credited below.
38 × 74½ in · 12″ or 14″ tall
Where to get it
- sealy.comQueen $960 · checked Oct 15 See price
- Split kingSplit King, Split Cal King See the list
Returns: 90 nights when purchased directly from sealy.com; retailer policies differ Details
We may earn a commission if you buy. Check the price for your exact size and height on the seller’s site.
The short version
Worth a look if
- Two heights, three feels
Good
- A coil bed with air, gel and support foams, as a 12″ tight top in Soft or Firm, or a 14″ Soft pillow top.
- 3 firmness choices: Soft, Firm, Soft Pillow Top
- Trial: 90 nights when purchased directly from sealy.com; retailer policies differ
- Height: 12″ or 14″
Think about
- The 90-night trial applies only to sealy.com purchases, and one owner wished their 12″ Icon were a bit softer.
- No owner reviews we could verify yet
Based on the maker’s published specs and terms, and the owner reviews linked below. We haven’t slept on it. Something wrong? Tell us.
What owners say
No owner reviews we can verify yet A small set of real reviews, each linked to its source. Not a star rating.
No owner feedback we can use yet.
What people liked
No supported praise summary in the sample.
What to weigh up
No substantive concern verified in this small sample. This is a gap in the evidence, not proof of no drawbacks.
What independent reviewers found
- NapLab (May 2026): Rated 6/10. Better for back and stomach sleepers; little sinkage for side sleepers. Good cooling, low motion transfer, edges sank more than average. Tester found the foams dry and crunchy and worried about early sagging; bottom-18% overall score. Tested the Costco-sold Icon (one medium feel, unit made Sep 2025); Sealy.com's Icon in Firm, Soft and Pillow Top Soft may differ. NapLab discloses affiliate commissions. Read it ↗
Their testing, in our words. We haven’t tested these mattresses ourselves, and we don’t repeat their scores.
Sources & sample limits
No usable owner sources. Sample: 0 owner reports.
Owner comments gathered from Reddit via RedditRecs were removed: RedditRecs and Reddit ask automated tools not to collect their content.
Research checked October 14, 2026. These are sourced observations, not our own product tests or a star rating.
Every size it comes in
Twin38 × 74½ inAs listedTwin XL38 × 79½ inAs listedFull53 × 74½ inAs listedQueen60 × 79½ inAs listedKing76 × 79½ inAs listedCal King72 × 83½ inAs listedSplit King38 × 79½ inAs listedSplit Cal King36 × 83½ inAs listed
Taken from the maker’s size options, in the inches it publishes. Tap a size to compare every mattress made in it. Sizes marked “as listed” don’t exactly match a standard size, so check your frame.
Price for every size
From the maker’s site on Oct 24, 2026. Prices change often, so check before you buy.
Video reviews
How it compares
Beside the most similar mattresses from other brands.
| IconSealy | AS2 HybridAmerisleep | Original HybridBear | Pro HybridBear | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid |
| Queen price | $960 | $1,249 | $829 | $1,299 |
| Height | 12″ or 14″ | — | 11″ | 13″ |
| Trial | 90 nights | 100 nights | 365 nights | 365 nights |
| Odd sizes | None | None | None | None |
| Expert reviews | 1 | 4 | 1 | 4 |
What’s inside
- 1MoistureProtect cover with Surface-Guard Technology
- 2SealyComfort Air Foam
- 3SealyComfort Gel Foam
- 4SealySupport Gel Foam
- 5SealyStability Coils
- 6Coil Edge
- Feel
- Soft, Firm, Soft Pillow Top
- Height
- 12″ or 14″
- Custom sizes
- Not offered for this model
Returns and ordering
Trial and returns
90 nights when purchased directly from sealy.com; retailer policies differ
Before you order
- Measure inside the frame, not the old mattress
- Check clearance above for the height you pick
- Make sure your base supports it
- Buy sheets in the same exact size
Questions
What is it made of?
Coil-based: SealyComfort Air Foam, SealyComfort Gel Foam, SealySupport Gel Foam over SealyStability coils with coil edge; MoistureProtect cover. Tight top 12", pillow top 14". sealy.com does not label it hybrid or innerspring.
How firm is it?
Soft, Firm, Soft Pillow Top That’s the maker’s description; we haven’t measured it.
Which sizes and heights can I get?
8 sizes, 12″ or 14″. See every size. Confirm your exact size and height with the seller.
Are the reviews about this exact mattress?
No owner reviews we can verify yet. Owner comments gathered from Reddit via RedditRecs were removed: RedditRecs and Reddit ask automated tools not to collect their content.
Where did this information come from?
- layers, heights, sizes, $960 queen, trial, warranty, 4.8/5 (11)
- sizes checked 2026-10-17: size selector lists Twin, Twin Long (Twin XL), Full, Queen, King, CA King, Split King, Split CA King; size FAQ gives Twin 38x74.5, Twin XL 38x79.5, Full 53x74.5, Queen 60x79.5, King 76x79.5, CA King 72x83.5, Split King 38 each piece x 79.5, Split CA King 36 each piece x 83.5. Moved inches out of size names into dims; no made-to-measure offered.
Checked 2026-10-15. Specs and terms can change.
Similar mattresses
All mattresses
HybridBrand product image
HybridBrand product image
HybridBrand product image
HybridBrand product image